Apr 20, 2011 eichmann, revisited 50 years after his trial in jerusalem, here are thoughts on the man in the glass booth, as witnessed by one of israels rare tv personnel at the time. She was referring to the fact that eichmann was a thoughtless, ordinary, unspectacular bourgeois middlemanagement type, able to engage in the worst atrocities because he literally could not see beyond his immediate surroundings to any moral or human issues. In 1942, the einstazgruppenthe mobile killing units of the sssurrounded the. K zetnik, rivka yosselevska, and moshe beisky became living symbols of. Transcripts from the archives of the israeli police. The eichmann trial has been one of the most important formative events. Some have criticized it as a mere political or jewish trial, while others argued eichmann played a limited role in advancing international law, in particular, the development of universal jurisdiction and. He was a leader in the nazi party in germany and played a. She was happily married and had a daughter named merkele. In her 2011 book eichmann before jerusalem, based largely on the sassen interviews and eichmanns notes made while in exile, bettina stangneth argues instead that eichmann was an ideologically motivated antisemite and lifelong committed nazi who intentionally built a persona as a faceless bureaucrat for presentation at the trial. Fifty years ago, adolf eichmann went to trial in israel for war crimes during world war ii. The person who wrote the memoir was rivka yosselevska, a woman who. The proceedings were one of the first trials widely televised, and brought nazi atrocities to a worldwide audience. I want you to tell me now about the execution of jews who were alleged to shirk work.
On december, 1961 the court found eichmann guilty on most articles of the indictment, and on the 15th of that same month, sentenced him. She was referring to the fact that eichmann was a thoughtless, ordinary, unspectacular bourgeois middlemanagement type, able to engage in the worst atrocities because he literally could not see beyond his immediate. The eichmann trial did not turn into a trial of the federal republic. After being found and captured in argentina, nazi leader adolf eichmann, known as the architect of the final solution, was put on trial in israel in 1961. She does present new evidence about eichmanns persona and thinking, based mainly on the socalled argentina papers, which took nearly 20 years to emerge completely. Rivka yosselevska rivka yosselevska was a belarusian jew from the village of zagorodski, near pinsk. Many thanks go to deborah lipstadt for doing three things in the eichmann trial. I think this is a really excellent piece of work and it makes me want to read more from lipstadt. The excitement and interest surrounding the trial had little to do with questions about its outcome.
Adam kirsch and rivka galchen on the continuing controversy over. Lipstadt is dorot professor of modern jewish history and holocaust studies at emory university and the author of several studies of the holocaust. The 1961 trial of adolf eichmann held in an israeli courtroom and broadcast around the globe, was a benchmark event in the historiography of the holocaust, especially in israel where the trial proved a watershed experience for survivors and citizens of the new jewish state. Fifty years later, why does eichmann in jerusalem remain. Historian deborah lipstadts overview of the eichmann trial is a useful summary of an event that can offer some lessons for our own times, and newly declassified u. Raffi eitan, who took part in eichmanns capture in argentina, rivka yosselevska, who gave testimony at the trial a survivor of the killing pits of the jews of pohost zagorodski, belarus, where her entire family was murdered by members of the einsatzgruppen and local collaborators in the summer of. The trial of adolf eichmann summary companion web site to pbs documentary on the trial of adolf eichmann for crimes against the jewish people.
Lipstadt explains all of the effects that the eichmann trial has had on subsequent history and on the historyof the holocaust. Would that be a photograph from the camp at sobibor. National jewish book award finalist 2012 part of the jewish encounter series. The title of the book was we shall never forget both in english and french. Weidenfeld and nicolson, 1963 war crime trials 666 pages. Sep 21, 2014 much of the reaction to the book hinges on how these new findings reflect on hannah arendts eichmann in jerusalem, her 1963 work based on her witnessing of eichmanns trial, which famously depicted him as the embodiment of the banality of evil. In her 2011 book eichmann before jerusalem, based largely on the sassen interviews and eichmann s notes made while in exile, bettina stangneth argues instead that eichmann was an ideologically motivated antisemite and lifelong committed nazi who intentionally built a persona as a faceless bureaucrat for presentation at the trial. The capture of ss lieutenant colonel adolf eichmann by israeli. Fifty years later fifty years ago one of the chief operators of the mass execution of jews was tried for crimes against humanity. Between now and that date the israelis will try to find a way to get a renewal. I covered the eichmann trial at jerusalem in 1961 for the new yorker, where this account, slightly abbreviated, was originally published in february and march, 1963. Baron a historian, not an eyewitness or a jurist, i shall concern myself with the historical situation of the jewish people before, during, and after the nazi onslaughtthe greatest catastrophe in jewish history, which has known many catastrophes. In 1960, the israeli government abducted key holocaust organizer adolf eichmann from argentina and put him on trial in jerusalem the following year.
On the 50th anniversary of the adolf eichmann trial, historian deborah lipstadt explains the worldwide fascination with the case and how it changed justice. Testimony of rivka yosselevska at zagrodski einsatzgruppen. Eichmann, revisited 50 years after his trial in jerusalem, here are thoughts on the man in the glass booth, as witnessed by one of israels rare tv personnel at the time. The capture of ss lieutenant colonel adolf eichmann by israeli agents in argentina in may of 1960 and his subsequent trial in jerusalem by an israeli court electrified the world. Eichmann s trial in jerusalem verdict the panel of district court judges who considered the eichmann case as court of first resort comprised.
Nineteen years after her escape from the execution pit she told her story at the eichmann trial in jerusalem. Photographs the eichmann trial, held before a special tribunal of the jerusalem district court, began on april 11, 1961, and aroused international interest in the events of the holocaust. Stangneths book, although far more respectful of arendts work than her detractors are, does not address these questions or throw much light on their philosophical context. The trial of adolf eichmann session 21, part 5 attorney general. Rivka yosselevska rivka yoselewska testifying at the trial of adolf eichmann in jerusalem on the evening of 14 august 1942, the first day of the hebrew month of ellul, a friday, the ss surrounded the ghetto in the village of zagrodski, near pinsk in belarus belorussia, home to five hundred jewish families. Includes resource material and school classroom activities related to the trial as well biographical information on eichmann and photographs of eichmann. Hannah arendts interpretation of the trial of adolf eichmann remains. Yet the first of the nuremberg trials, in 1945, and the trial of adolph eichmann, in 1961. After the nazi invasion of belarus, yosselevskas family was forced to enter a jewish ghetto with 500 other familes. University of pennsylvania press, 2009 yablonka, hanna. The testimony given by those he sought to murder proved a turning point in. The trial of adolf eichmann trial participants then. Mrs yosselevska, after they left the place, you went right next to the grave. A farmer took pity on rivka yosselevska, hid her and fed her.
The channel is a joint effort between yad vashem and t. The eichmann trial european jewry before and after hitler by salo w. Eichmann, had, in fact, been living under an assumed name in argentina and had been brought to israel without the knowl. Many trials of nazis and their collaborators were held following world war iiin the american and britishoccupied zones of postwar germany, in france the trial of vichy prime ministerpierre lavel, and in poland the trials of concentration camp commandants rudolf hoss and amon goth. There are still quite a number of eichmanns around. Predictably, however, an account of eichmann s crimes was woven into their stories arising out of his various posts in the ss, as coordinator, organizer, and director of the deportation of jews to the ghettoes and annihilation camps. Eichmann in ungarn 1961 had been commissioned for the. In the nearly 50 years since its publication, her account of those proceedings.
To write about the trial of adolf eichmann is to put its most notorious court reporter, hannah arendt, in the dock. The capture and trial of adolf eichmann moshe pearlman. Most people, both those in the courtroom and those beyond, expected eichmann to be found guilty. Apr 10, 2011 to write about the trial of adolf eichmann is to put its most notorious court reporter, hannah arendt, in the dock.
The commotion and noise on that night, recalled rivka yosselevska, was not. Photographs of witnesses in the eichmann trial, 196061. Food is scarce if a family has nothing to trade on the black market. It consists of photographs only, and amongst them there is one on which i recognised eichmann. Mar 14, 2011 fifty years ago, adolf eichmann went to trial in israel for war crimes during world war ii. The commotion and noise on that night, recalled rivka yosselevska, was not customary, and we felt.
I this paper is compiled from a book i recently completed, tik plili 4061, medinat. This is a revised and enlarged edition of the book which first appeared in may, 1963. The eichmann trial channel contains over 200 hours of trial sessions and a compilation of testimonies. Ansbacher, mordechaiwitness to conditions in the theresienstadt concentration camp, czechoslovakia bach, gavrieldeputy state attorney and. Various cus of woman giving evidence with cutins shot of eichmann listening.
There she survived until the soviet army came in the summer of 1944. When rivka s husband, fiszel, died in the early 1930s, she and her oldest daughter, channa, opened a newspaper kiosk near the kaluszyn railroad station. The new yorker magazine began publishing eichmann in jerusalem by hannah arendt on this date in 1963. The structure of legality and the construction of heroic memory at the eichmann trial, in 2 law and literature. Aug 27, 2009 on reaching the destination, rivka yosselevska saw that the people from the truck had already been taken off, and were undressed, all lined up.
National jewish book award finalist 2012 part of the jewish encounter series the capture of ss lieutenant colonel adolf eichmann by israeli agents in argentina in may of 1960 and his subsequent trial in jerusalem by an israeli court electrified the world. Raffi eitan, who took part in eichmann s capture in argentina, rivka yosselevska, who gave testimony at the trial a survivor of the killing pits of the jews of pohost zagorodski, belarus, where her entire family was murdered by members of the einsatzgruppen and local collaborators in the summer of. The banality of evil line was a small line, taken out of context and used in a campaign against arendts book before it was published. He was a leader in the nazi party in germany and played a major role in the deportation of jews to. Eichmann trial journal of international criminal justice. Rivka and several others managed to survive the ordeal, and by lying in the mass grave for three days and three nights she was eventually found and hidden by a farmer. G43 e57 1964 find in a library near you external link an analysis of the legal issues involved in the eichmann trial, written by the official observer for the international commission of jurists. The prosecution in the eichmann trial exaggerated eichmanns.
In 2012 i read hannah arendts eichmann in jerusalem, and found it perplexing and at times difficult to understand. The eichmann trial raised so much awareness that subsequent national conflicts were, and still are, interpreted in relation to the holocaust as the most extreme of all jewish catastrophes. After the nazi invasion of belarus, yosselevska s family was forced to enter a jewish ghetto with 500 other familes. The memoirist was a witness at adolf eichmanns trial in 1961. A critical look at the eichmann trial case western reserve. Baade introduction on may 23, 196o, prime minister david ben gurion of israel announced in the knesseth israels parliament that adolf eichmann had been found. The subsidies were to continue until april 1st, 1964. Moshe bahir testimony about sobibor at the eichmann trial. The death and carnage during this period of time is hard to fathom, and out of the depths of evil there are many stories of survival. On september 25, 1942, 67yearold rivka and more than 3,000 other jews were deported from kaluszyn to. Events such as the eichmann trial benefit from being revisited from time to time as time goes by.
The fivepart article, covering adolf eichmanns 1961 trial for crimes against humanity for which he would be executed on may 31, 1962, was released as a book and aroused enormous controversy. On the evening of 14 august 1942, the first day of the hebrew month of ellul, a friday, the ss surrounded the ghetto in the village of zagrodski, near pinsk in belarus belorussia, home to five hundred jewish families. Jan 11, 2015 the televised trial of adolf eichmann in 1961 was a landmark in holocaust history. Rivka would like to help raizel in the communal kitchen for poor jewish families. Rivka yoselewska testifying at the trial of adolf eichmann in jerusalem. Memories of the eichmann trial film studies center. Do you remember the hangings of the jews in ciechanow. Nineteen years after her escape from the execution pit she told her story at. Thus, i read this recent book by deborah lipstadt, the eichmann trial written to commemorate the 50th anniversary of the beginning of eichmanns trial in jerusalem, april 11, 1961.
A woman gives evidence at trial of nazi adolf eichmann. The televised trial of adolf eichmann in 1961 was a landmark in holocaust history. Rivka lived with her story until nineteen years later, when adolf eichmann was put on trial in jerusalem. The 1961 trial of nazi arch criminal adolf eichmann changed the philosophy and future thinking of the state of israel. The story of rivka yosselevska the holocaust killed millions of men, women, and children, and was unquestionably one of the greatest atrocities that ever occurred. The eichmann trial united states holocaust memorial museum. It was some three kilometres from the village, by a kind of hillock.
On the 50th anniversary of nazi criminal adolf eichmanns trial, yad vashem released video documentation of the trial, including over 200 hours of trial sessions and a compilation of testimonies. Rivka yosselevskawitness to einsatzgruppen massacres. He mentions the declarations of avraham aviel and rivka yosselevska, and eichmann s involvement in the decision to use gas for murder of. Goodreads members who liked the eichmann trial also liked. Far better to my mind than arendts book eichmann in jerusalem is. Later, he helped her join a group of jews hiding in the forest. On may 8th, 1961, yosselevska bore witness at the trial of adolf eichmann in jerusalem.
She tells of how members of her family were shot down before her eyes. The trial of adolf eichmann national center for jewish film. Attorney general hausner argues to the judges that the precedents set prior to the eichmann trial can be used to indict eichmann without charges of conspiracy, and rather his actions should be seen as corroboration with conspiracy duplicate footage from tape 2226. Few controversial books remain controversial 50 years after they were published. Find books like the eichmann trial from the worlds largest community of readers. The panel of district court judges who considered the eichmann case as court of first resort comprised. The public debate it sparked on where, how, and by whom nazi war criminals should be brought to justice, and the. Apr 10, 2011 the excitement and interest surrounding the trial had little to do with questions about its outcome. Yet the first of the nuremberg trials, in 1945, and the trial of adolph eichmann, in 1961, remain the. Investigatewhos whoat the trial trial participants select a participant listed alphabetically by last name to see a photo during the trial and in 1996, along with excerpts of testimony and reflections on the eichmann trial today. Some have criticized it as a mere political or jewish trial, while others argued eichmann played a limited role in advancing international law, in particular, the development of universal jurisdiction and individual liability. Much has been written on the eichmann trial by scholars, historians, journalists, intellectuals and the central players during the trial. The survivors who followed the trials proceedings, as well as chief prosecutor gideon hausner, also viewed the trial as an opportunity to educate a.
876 1475 387 1295 1305 1336 1292 831 306 226 310 1253 127 574 898 947 371 498 718 106 358 1024 1261 630 192 1286 528 270 1486 1275 1157 539 1286 823 65 949 218 241 1014 296 1386 1180 709 283 345 1198 1463 1128 1404 8